![]() ![]() |
Animal Defenders of Westchester |
|
![]()
Home Page We advocate on all animal protection and exploitation issues, including experimentation, factory farming, rodeos, breeders and traveling animal acts. Animal Defenders of Westchester |
Articles Bane of companies, PETA spy reveals self for first time
By BONNIE PFISTER TRENTON, N.J. -- Lisa Leitten is finished living her double life. For the past three years, the soft-spoken, 30-year old moved from
Missouri to Texas to Virginia, applying for jobs at businesses
dealing with animals. She gave her real name, and some real details about
herself: a master's degree in animal psychology and prior work at a primate
sanctuary in Florida. What she didn't reveal was that she was also working for an animal
welfare organization, and that she wore a hidden camera to
document instances in which animals were treated with what she
calls horrific neglect and cruelty. Leitten called her last assignment for People for the Ethical Treatment
of Animals her most wrenching: nine months in a Virginia lab
owned by Princeton, N.J.-based biomedical firm Covance Co.
There, she says, monkeys were denied medical care and abused by
technicians. The company denies the claims, says it treats the
animals properly and has accused Leitten of illegally working under cover.
Two weeks ago, PETA presented Leitten's assertions about Covance in video
footage and a massive report to the U.S. Department of Agriculture, the Food
and Drug Administration, and Virginia prosecutors, calling for regulators to
shutter the company's Vienna, Va., lab. "This was my third assignment, and my final one," Leitten said in a
recent interview with The Associated Press, the first time she has
publicly revealed her identity. "You never forget the things that
you've seen." Leitten grew up an animal lover in a middle-class family in Buffalo, N.Y.
While in college in Ohio, a psychology class took her to a zoo to study
chimpanzee behavior. "My love of primates grew from that," she said. "They are such
intelligent, feeling animals, so like us." She earned her graduate degree at Central Washington University's
Chimpanzee and Human Communication Institute, famously home in the late
1960s to a chimpanzee who learned sign language. While in college, Leitten had become a vegetarian and found herself
increasingly concerned about animal welfare. PETA was a natural fit. But she was more comfortable working behind the scenes than marching in
rallies. The intrigue of undercover work outweighed her initial worries. "At first I thought, 'There's no way.' The fear of everything, of having
to wear covert equipment and move around. But then it sounded
sort of exciting at the same time," she said. Her first job began in May 2002, a nine-month stint at a Missouri lab
that produced pet food for Proctor & Gamble's Iams label. There, she claimed
she found animals that were injured, had untended wounds and receiving
unnecessary surgeries. Leitten documented her findings, quietly left the job
and let PETA make her allegations public. Retailer PetSmart and Iams severed contracts with the lab, which laid off
nearly half of its workers. Its owner accused PETA of playing on
corporations' fear of negative publicity rather than exposing legitimate
concerns. By July of 2003, Leitten resurfaced at her next assignment, a wildlife
refuge in Amarillo, Texas. PETA said it had received complaints of tigers
and monkeys housed in waste-laden cages and being fed spoiled food. Six months later, Leitten slipped out of Texas, and PETA held another
news conference with another damning video. A subsequent USDA review
backed up the group's assertions. For what she says was her final assignment, Leitten was hired as a
primate technician for Covance. Leitten's camera work, and the report issued by PETA, depict frightened
monkeys being yanked from their cages and handled roughly by aggressive,
often cursing technicians. She says she watched animals suffer with festering wounds, and that tubes
were forced into their sinuses for research medicine to be administered,
causing them to scream, bleed and vomit. Monkeys were housed alone in cages
that were hosed down with the animals still inside, dripping and shivering,
she said. Laurene Isip, a Covance spokeswoman, says the company has complied with
animal welfare regulations for its half-century in business, and doubted the
credibility of PETA's charges. The company called Leitten's actions illegal. Legal experts agree. "As an employee she has a legal right to be there, but she's there to
fulfill and execute on the tasks and responsibilities give to her by her
employer. She's not there to fulfill her own private agenda," said Scott Vernick,
a Philadelphia lawyer specializing in professional responsibility and legal
ethics. Bruce Weinstein, who has written four books on ethics, said even noble
ends do not justify deceptive means. "The question is, can those perhaps noble ends be achieved legally and
ethically? Can one legitimately document abuses that occur without
pretending to be someone one is not, or breaking the law, or
videotaping things surreptitiously?" Mary Beth Sweetland, PETA's research and investigations director, said
she now has two staffers working covertly, the latest of dozens of
investigations conducted by the group's over 25 years. In some instances, as at Covance, PETA says its moles have signed
nondisclosure forms and claim to try to stay within the law by never
removing anything from work sites or by revealing proprietary information.
So far only one company that's been infiltrated has sued: product-testing
lab Huntingdon Life Sciences. The Somerset County-based company dropped its
case in return for PETA promising to not infiltrate it again for at least
five years. "It's a risk we're willing to take," Sweetland said. "If it weren't for
these investigations, no one would no what was going on." For her part, Leitten says her time as a spy was spent worrying about the
animals, not about being caught. She said she spent nights at home with her
two dogs, weeping and writing up what she had seen during the
day. "That's why people only last in this job a couple of years," said Leitten,
who asked that her current residence not be revealed. "I get migraines, a
lot of anxiety. But if something can change for the animals, and their
lives will be better in some way, then all those sleepless nights and
crying at home will be worth it." On the Net: Copyright 2005 Newsday Inc. TO SUBMIT LETTERS TO THE EDITOR :
[email protected] NEWSDAY Letters to the Editor Newsday 80-02 Kew Gardens Rd. Kew Gardens,
NY 11415-1154 Fax: 718-793-6422 ARTICLE TITLE: Bane of companies, PETA spy reveals self for first time
ARTICLE SOURCE: newsday.com/news/local/wire/newyork/ny-bc-ny--petaspy0530may30,0,3259807.story
________________ May Be Forwarded (cut & paste) Fair Use Notice: This document may contain
copyrighted material whose use has not been specifically authorized by the
copyright owners. We believe that this not-for-profit, educational use on
the Web constitutes a fair use of the copyrighted material (as provided for
in section 107 of the US Copyright Law). If you wish to use this copyrighted
material for purposes of your own that go beyond fair use, you must obtain
permission from the copyright owner. |
Your comments and
inquiries are welcome
This site is hosted and maintained by:
The Mary T. and Frank L. Hoffman Family Foundation
Thank you for visiting all-creatures.org.
Since