Committee to Abolish Sport Hunting


Letters to the Editor and Others

Deer Donation Not a Good Deed

Sent on Jan 5, 2004 to the St. Joseph News-Press (MO)

An article published on January 1, reported that resource scientist Lonnie Hansen said deer hunters donate about forty-tons of venison to food banks and charities. Unfortunately, what Mr. Hansen and others may see as a good deed may in fact be hurting the very people they intend to help.

Since many hunters do not eat the animals they kill, they try to justify their violent acts by donating dead deer "to the needy."

What is troubling is that this meat is not inspected by the USDA and there are no assurances that the meat is fit for human consumption.

When hunters in New York State tried to pass a bill absolving them of liability if the meat donated was unhealthy, the state Departments of Health, Social Services, and Agriculture and Markets spoke out against it.

The latter wrote in part: "We cannot, and should not, engage in selective enforcement of the law or establish separate standards of food safety. The poor and homeless are entitled to receive the same level of health protections from the government as those more fortunate. the general public should not be exposed unwittingly to the potential food safety risks of consuming wild game which are "processed" in this fashion."

When the Department Of Agriculture and Markets did make an unprecedented exception to their normal policy and inspected deer meat from a hunt in Rochester, they concluded: "All of the venison which was salvaged from the 'bait and shoot' operation in Rochester was found to be unfit for human consumption. We have seized (the meat) and will oversee its destruction."

When several years ago we called food banks, we were surprised to find that most hadn't received donations all. One food charity that had gotten a donation said it was a very small amount, and people complained about the taste and odor of the meat.

While hunters try to change their image from that of opportunistic killers of harmless animals to benevolent champions of the needy, the truth remains that their feeble attempt at public deception does very little good, and may indeed do a great deal of harm.

Joe Miele, Vice President
Wildlife Watch, Inc.
Box 562
New Paltz, NY 12561

Return to Letters to the Editor

We welcome your comments

| About C.A.S.H. | Action Alerts | C.A.S.H. Courier | Join | Letters | Main |


Copyright 2003 Committee to Abolish Sport Hunting

This site is sponsored and maintained by
The Mary T. and Frank L. Hoffman Family Foundation
Thank you for visiting
Since date.gif (1356 bytes)