Reprinted courtesy of Carol and Ted Barnett and the
Rochester Area Vegetarian Society
On July 25-29, the Barnett family had the distinct pleasure of attending
our 14th Vegetarian Summerfest in a row. After all these years, we find
much to learn and everything to enjoy. Each year brings new speakers,
and new topics and findings from “old” speakers. What follows is an
attempt to summarize some of the more valuable insights. (Persons who
have spoken at Rochester Area Vegetarian Society meetings are referred
to on a first-name basis!)
Paulette Chandler, MD, lectured on bone health. Vitamin D seems
to be the latest star in preserving bone health. Even if we achieve the
recommended calcium levels (1300 mg./day for ages 9-18, 1,000 mg./day
for ages 19-50, 1,200 mg./day for ages over 50), vitamin D is necessary
to pull calcium into the body. Persons taking in 1200 mg./day of calcium
and 800 IU of vitamin D have reduced fracture risk, but this benefit is
not shown at the same calcium levels with only 400 IU vitamin D. As we
age, the body’s ability to synthesize Vitamin D declines; 40 percent to
100 percent of the elderly have a vitamin D deficiency. Furthermore,
vitamin D2 (ergocalciferol, the type of vitamin D which is vegan in
origin), has only a 50 percent effective conversion rate. I asked Dr.
Chandler if this means we should take twice the recommended rate, and
she said yes. With many doctors recommending 1,000 IU daily, with an
upper limit of 2,000 IU, it seems we should all be taking at least 1,000
IU of D twice daily.
Chandler says the body absorbs only 500 mg. of calcium at a time, so if
you take supplements, they should be spaced throughout the day
accordingly.
Brenda Davis, MD, (who, by the way, was inducted into the
Vegetarian Hall of Fame at this conference), gave a talk on the optimal
diet, focusing on “foods that harm.” While she focused on many of the
usual suspects which are rare or absent in the typical vegan diet (such
as cholesterol and animal protein), she discussed two culprits that many
vegans consume, one of them a surprise. Most of us know that we should
avoid trans fatty acids, found in processed foods as “hydrogenated” or
“partially hydrogenated oil,” and in deep-fried fast foods for which we
can’t read the label. For me, the surprise was the frequent occurrence
of acrylamide, a probable carcinogen, in popular vegan foods. This
substance forms when starchy foods are cooked at a high temperature for
a long time. No one knows safe amounts, and the food industry is
stonewalling attempts to list or eliminate this substance. High levels
are found in grain beverages and potato chips, and lesser amounts in
roasted nut butters, crackers, and bread. The best policy seems to be to
eat more raw or cooked fruits and vegetables (boiling or steaming will
not produce acrylamide because the temperature is too low), and to eat
only a moderate amount of baked or fried potato and grain products.
George Eisman, RD, discussed the strong association between dairy
consumption and the hormone-related cancers: breast cancer in women and
prostate cancer in men. Taking the fat out of dairy products, as in skim
milk, does not solve the problem; as shown by the work of T. Colin
Campbell, Ph.D., the dairy protein itself (casein or caseinate, seen in
so many processed foods) is a potent carcinogen.
Caldwell Esselstyn, MD, describes the typical heart attack as
arising, not from a total blockage of a blood vessel, but from a minor
blockage that becomes inflamed, releases dangerous chemicals, and
becomes the site of a deadly clot. The episode can be triggered by a
single high-fat meal, which causes “immediate injury to the vascular
system.” For those with heart disease, Esselstyn advocates no added oil
and no high-fat foods such as nuts and avocados. When asked whether
healthy persons can have nuts and avocados, Esselstyn replied that: one
public health authority has stated that all men over 65 and women over
70 can be presumed to have heart disease, and autopsies of much younger
people show arterial plaques and; apparently healthy younger people
should avoid these foods if they need to lose weight.
Michael Greger, MD, gave an overview of the “Latest Science in
Human Nutrition,” having reviewed over 7,000 nutrition articles in the
past year. Some keynotes: Meat doubles the risk of bladder cancer – the
British Women’s Cohort Study shows that the more meat one consumes, the
greater the risk of breast cancer; Dairy products promote prostate
cancer, testicular cancer, and Parkinson’s disease; Dark green leafy
greens cut the risk of melanoma (deadly skin cancer) – in lab tests, if
you “drip broccoli” on cells in petri dishes, it protects them; Pinto
beans reduce biomarkers for heart disease; Berries are among the
healthiest fruits, protective against cancer and heart disease; Green
tea is antibacterial, antifungal, antitoxin, anti-cancer, and
anti-death! (associated with lower mortality); Soy protein prevents an
increase in abdominal fat, while casein (dairy protein) promotes it;
Cocoa powder lowers blood pressure, raises HDL (good cholesterol), and
may boost the immune system (Michael recommends the following pudding
recipe [silken tofu, cocoa powder, and date sugar or maple syrup, in the
food processor] and smoothie recipe [soy milk, cocoa powder, date sugar
or maple syrup in the blender; add frozen cherries or other fruit if
desired]); Bad news – vegetarians and vegans still not getting enough
vitamin B12 (take one 2000 mcg tablet [chewed or dissolved under the
tongue] once a week, or 10 to 100 mcg once a day); and not getting
enough iodine (use iodized salt or sea vegetables, but NOT hijiki, which
in some instances has high levels of arsenic); Michael’s favorite study
of the year, earning the gold medal: people who don’t eat meat have a
less intense, more attractive, and more pleasant “perceived body odor
hedonicity”– i.e., they smell better!
Milton Mills, MD, in a talk on “Exercise Fitness,” gave an
excellent (and motivating) explanation of the mechanism by which we
increase aerobic fitness. When one begins to exercise, one uses the
energy stored as glycogen in the muscles. When the glycogen is
exhausted, we feel exhausted (known as “hitting the wall”) and we move
on to the process of oxidizing the fat in our tissues to obtain energy.
Three things increase the efficiency of this process: stronger heart
pumping or cardiac output; greater capillary density and; greater
mitochondrial density, mitochondria being the cell bodies which receive
and use oxygen. All three of these things increase with prompting, i.e.,
the more we ask our body to do them, the more they will develop. Another
factor of the equation, if one wants to increase performance on a given
occasion (e.g., a race), is to increase the store of glycogen in the
muscles so you “hit the wall” later. This is known as “carbohydrate
loading.” Milton says it is done most efficiently by exercising to
exhaustion about 4 days before the event (depleting the glycogen), and
then eating lots of carbs in the day or two before the event (like
batteries that should be totally drained before recharging). Be sure to
take in plenty of water as well, as it’s needed to store glycogen.
Pamela Rice gave talks on the environmental impact of meat and fishing,
and the cost (in dollars, environmental devastation, and adverse health
effects) of federal subsidies to the meat and dairy industries. In the
U.S., 70 percent of our grain goes to feed animals. One pound of animal
protein takes 100 times as much water as one pound of plant protein, and
eight times as much energy. A recent study by the Food and Agriculture
Organization of the UN shows that, worldwide, livestock generates more
greenhouse gases (which contribute to global warming) than all forms of
transportation combined (18percent vs. 13percent).
Go on to
Vegetarian Journey
Return to Fall 2007 Issue