See PDF
8/15/11
Dr. Elizabeth Goldentyer 8/15/11
USDA/APHIS/AC
920 Main Campus Drive, Suite 2000
Raleigh, NC 27606
Dr. Goldentyer,
I am writing to you today to file an Official Complaint against the Harvard
Medical School (14-R-0019), and to insist that serious punitive action be taken
against this facility for recent violations of the Animal Welfare Act.
In a USDA inspection report dated 7/19/11 this facility is cited for multiple
violations of the Animal Welfare Act including a citation for Unqualified
Personnel. This citation for unqualified personnel resulted from the overdosing
of a primate during surgery resulting in untreatable renal failure, which made
euthanasia unavoidable.
As you know, this is the second incident of negligence related to the death
of a primate at this facility in just over 1 year. On June 29, 2010, Harvard
received five USDA citations for violating the Animal Welfare Act. The
violations involved unqualified personnel inadequate veterinary care, and
inadequate cleaning/sanitation procedures. This inspection report recounted an
incident in which a primate was found dead in a cage that had just gone through
the cage-washing system.
It is clear that the staff of this lab, according to the inspection reports
of the USDA is UNQUALIFIED. This has not changed in over a year. Why has serious
action not been taken against this facility? How many more animals have to die
due to negligence before the Eastern Regional Office of the USDA does something
about it?
I know that your office considers major violations of the Animal Welfare Act
to be very serious in nature, especially when these violations take the lives of
animals. The treatment of animals at this facility illustrates attitudes of
carelessness and negligence that must be punished so that meaningful changes can
be made. Therefore, I also insist that you take the most severe action allowable
under the Animal Welfare Act and immediately begin the process of issuing a fine
against the Harvard Medical School.
I look forward to hearing from you in the near future about the fate of this
facility.
Sincerely,
Michael A. Budkie, A.H.T.,
Executive Director, SAEN
Attachments: USDA - Inspection Report - 19 Jul 2011
Rats, mice, birds, amphibians and other animals have
been excluded from coverage by the Animal Welfare Act. Therefore research
facility reports do not include these animals. As a result of this
situation, a blank report, or one with few animals listed, does not mean
that a facility has not performed experiments on non-reportable animals. A
blank form does mean that the facility in question has not used covered
animals (primates, dogs, cats, rabbits, guinea pigs, hamsters, pigs,
sheep, goats, etc.). Rats and mice alone are believed to comprise over 90%
of the animals used in experimentation. Therefore the majority of animals
used at research facilities are not even counted.
We welcome your comments and questions