Grant Number: 5R01AI058107-02
Project Title: PRIMATE MODEL AND PATHOGENESIS OF ANTHRAX SEPSIS
PI Information: SHINICHIRO KUROSAWA,
shinichiro-kurosawa@omrf.org
Abstract: DESCRIPTION (provided by applicant): The threat of
bioterrorism has become a reality since the attacks with Bacillus
anthracis (anthrax) in the fall of 2001. The virulence of B.anthracis
depends on a tripartite exotoxin and an anti-phagocytic bacterial
capsule. In patients, clinical anthrax is both septicemia and toxemia,
with features of an uncompensated inflammatory response. The victims of
bioterrorism with inhaled or cutaneous anthrax developed a severe
coagulopathy and experienced organ failure and other complications from
disseminated intravascular coagulation. These responses are similar to
the uncompensated inflammatory responses which contribute directly to
the lethality and morbidity in established baboon models of E.coli-mediated
sepsis. Activated protein C (APC), a member of the protein C pathway, is
an important regulator of this host coagulation and inflammatory
response to sepsis. First proposed by our group for the treatment of
E.coli-mediated sepsis in the baboon, APC is now an FDA-approved therapy
for patients with severe sepsis. The recent phase 3 clinical trial
demonstrated that APC as an adjunct to standard anti-infective therapy
significantly improved patient outcome. However, the effect of APC has
not been tested in sepsis involving an exotoxin. We hypothesize that the
protein C pathway plays a major role in modulating responses to
B.anthracis septicemia-toxemia and that APC will reduce inflammation and
mortality induced by B.anthracis. In order to test this, we will develop
i.v. non-human primate models of B. anthracis (toxigenic,
non-encapsulated Sterne strain) sepsis and anthrax toxemia.
Dose-response studies will establish the concentration ranges of
susceptibility. We will use these models to evaluate the contribution of
protein C pathway members and other hemostatic regulators to the
pathogenesis and lethality of anthrax infection. Antibodies that block
the function of protein C pathway members (e.g., protein C,
thrombomodulin, endothelial protein C receptor) will be infused with
sub-lethal challenge to evaluate individual contributions to
inflammatory responses andmortality. Changes at the tissue level
(coagulation, inflammation, apoptosis, signaling) will be assessed with
immunohistochemical, confocal and electron microscopic imaging and
microarrays. Changes in cellular (neutrophil activation) and soluble
mediators (e.g, sEPCR, TNF-alpha, IL-6, elastase, D-dimer) will be
followed with flow cytometry and ELISAs. Using the baboon models, we
will determine the effect of APC administration on mortality and
pathological changes induced by B.anthracis or toxin challenge. These
studies will establish non-human primate models of anthrax infection,
identify molecular pathways unique to toxin action, identify regulatory
pathways important to host defense against B.anthracis, provide
clinically-relevant animal models for future evaluation of new
therapeutic approaches, and determine the role of APC and the protein C
pathway in regulating anthrax-mediated pathogenesis.
Public Health Relevance:
This Public Health Relevance is not available.
Thesaurus Terms:
Bacillus anthracis, anthrax, disseminated intravascular coagulation,
host organism interaction, inflammation, nonhuman therapy evaluation,
pathologic process, protein C, septicemia
anthrax toxin, bacteria infection mechanism, coagulation factor VII,
heparin, microorganism disease chemotherapy, spore
baboon, bioterrorism /chemical warfare, confocal scanning microscopy,
electron microscopy, enzyme linked immunosorbent assay, flow cytometry,
immunocytochemistry, microarray technology
Institution: OKLAHOMA MEDICAL RESEARCH FOUNDATION
825 N. E. 13TH STREET
OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 731045005
Fiscal Year: 2006
Department:
Project Start: 15-JAN-2005
Project End: 31-DEC-2009
ICD: NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF ALLERGY AND INFECTIOUS DISEASES
IRG: SAT
Am J Pathol. 2006 August; 169(2): 433–444.
doi: 10.2353/ajpath.2006.051330. PMCID: PMC1698797
Copyright © American Society for Investigative Pathology
Sepsis and Pathophysiology of Anthrax in a Nonhuman
Primate Model
Deborah J. Stearns-Kurosawa,* Florea Lupu,† Fletcher B.
Taylor, Jr.,† Gary Kinasewitz,‡ and Shinichiro Kurosawa*
From the Departments of Free Radical Biology and Aging
Research* and Cardiovascular Biology,† Oklahoma Medical
Research Foundation, Oklahoma City; and the Department of Medicine,‡
Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine, University of Oklahoma Health
Sciences Center, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma
Accepted May 4, 2006.
Bacillus anthracis, a zoonotic toxigenic gram-positive, spore-forming
rod, is the cause of clinical anthrax disease. There has been a
significant resurgence in biomedical anthrax-related research because of
the bioterrorism attacks in the United States.1–6 As a result, the
genomic sequence of B. anthracis has been completed,7 exotoxin crystal
structures solved,8,9 and cellular toxin receptors identified.10,11 The
virulence of B. anthracis bacilli is primarily governed by products of
two large plasmids that code for secreted exotoxins and an exterior
capsule.12,13 The capsule, composed of poly-γ-D-glutamic acid, has anti-phagocytic
properties and contributes to bacterial dissemination.14 Under the
control of the atxA gene product,15 the bacteria produce exotoxin
components: protective antigen (PA) serves as a conduit for
translocation of lethal factor (metalloprotease) and edema factor (adenylate
cyclase) into the cell for toxicity and injury.16
However, the pathophysiology of anthrax as a septic disease is less well
defined. Sepsis is defined as a host systemic inflammatory response to
infection and is complicated in severe sepsis with organ dysfunction,
hypoperfusion, and coagulation abnormalities.17 Clinical and pathology
data from the victims of anthrax bioterrorism,1,18 as well as a 1979
inadvertent release of military-grade anthrax spores in Russia,19,20
show evidence of concomitant pulmonary edema, inflammation, and
disseminated intravascular coagulation (DIC). To mimic anthrax,
considerable work in animal models, including rhesus monkeys and
chimpanzees, has been done using administration of spores by various
routes, including aerosol.21–24 These studies investigated important
spore dose-response relationships and subsequent pathology observations
were consistent with a general consensus that B. anthracis introduced by
the respiratory route results in a fulminating septicemia rather than a
primary pulmonary infection.22 However, a consistent picture of
pathophysiology progression is difficult to ascertain from these
inhalational models. There is significant individual variation in gross
and microscopic pathology of rhesus monkeys after challenge,24 probably
attributable to dose-response issues because it is difficult to know how
many of the inhaled spores actually result in infection. Although organ
hemorrhage, edema, and inflammatory infiltrates were noted in some
animals, a systematic analysis of inflammatory or coagulation biomarkers
was not available. These observations are further compounded by the
current paradigm, based on toxic murine models, which describes anthrax
pathogenesis as being governed by exotoxin bioactivities and host
inflammatory or coagulopathic responses as playing little role.25–27
These disparities gain importance when extrapolating experimental data
to patients because vaccine development and clinical management
decisions are based on an understanding of disease pathogenesis.
The current study addresses whether the pathogenesis of the bacteremic
phase of anthrax is governed by predominately noninflammatory pathways
as suggested by toxic murine models or is represented by uncompensated
inflammation and coagulation responses to the infection. We have adapted
our nonhuman primate model of E. coli sepsis that has been extensively
characterized28,29 and has served as the basis30 for clinical studies
that culminated in Food and Drug Administration approval of an adjunct
therapy for patients with severe sepsis.31 We chose infection by
infusion of bacteria for reproducible dosing, because with a high B.
anthracis spore infection dose, the onset of bacteremia is rapid, with
dissemination within 24 ~ 48 hours,14,32 and overwhelming.23 This
approach mimics the bacteremia stage during which patients become sick
and seek medical attention. Unencapsulated B. anthracis 34F2 Sterne
strain was used because this strain produces toxin in quantities similar
to the natural fully virulent strains.33 The results illustrate the
physiological, hemostatic, cellular, and inflammatory responses to
anthrax, as well as distinctive lung pathology that may be a unique
feature of anthrax.
Animals
Infusion methods were essentially identical to those used for E. coli34
and Shiga toxin 1.35 Papio c. cynocephalus or Papio c. anubis baboons
were purchased from the breeding colony maintained at the University of
Oklahoma Health Sciences Center (Dr. Gary White, Director). Baboons were
free of tuberculosis, weighed 6 to 8 kg, had leukocyte concentrations of
5000/mm3 to 14,000/mm3, and hematocrits exceeding 36%. T0-hour blood
samples were drawn from the cephalic vein catheter followed by bacteria
infusion for 2 hours. Levofloxacin infusion (7 mg/kg) was initiated at
T4 hours and repeated daily. Infusion studies were performed at the
University of Oklahoma Health Sciences Center. All experiments were
approved by the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee and the
Institutional Biosafety Committee of the Oklahoma Medical Research
Foundation and the University of Oklahoma Health Sciences Center.
Bacteria
Vegetative bacteria germinated from Bacillus anthracis 34F2 Sterne
strain spores (Colorado Serum Co., Boulder, CO) were washed and
resuspended in sterile saline for infusion. Live bacteria were
quantitated using the Bac-Titer-Glo microbial cell viability assay (Promega,
Madison, WI). In preliminary studies, a standard curve of viable
bacteria (BacTiter-Glo) versus viable bacteria obtained by traditional
plating methods (CFU/ml) was established. This relationship was very
reproducible (r = 0.99; n = 3), permitting use of the luminescence assay
for determining viable bacteria counts, rather than counting colonies on
plates, which can be difficult with B. anthracis because of chaining.
CFU/kg dosage was calculated by reference to this standard curve.
Infusion Procedures
Briefly, the baboons were fasted for 24 hours before the study, with
free access to water. They were immobilized the morning of the
experiment with ketamine (14 mg/kg, i.m.) and sodium pentobarbital
administered through a percutaneous catheter in the cephalic vein of the
forearm to maintain a light level of surgical anesthesia (2 mg/kg,
approximately every 20 to 40 minutes). This catheter was also used to
infuse the B. anthracis bacteria and sterile saline to replace
insensible loss. An additional percutaneous catheter was inserted into
the saphenous vein in one hind limb and the catheter advanced to the
inferior vena cava; this catheter was used for sampling blood. Baboons
were orally intubated and positioned on their left side on a heat pad.
Our typical infusion protocol involved blood draw at T0, followed
immediately by bacteria infusion at the appropriate concentration for 2
hours, typically at 0.2 ml/minute.
|