See PDF
April 23, 2012
FROM:
SAEN
1081-B St. Rt. 28 #280
Milford, Ohio 45015
(513) 575-5517
www.saenonline.org
TO:
Dr. Robert Gibbens
Director, Western Region
USDA/APHIS/AC
2150 Center Ave.
Building B, Mailstop 3W11
Fort Collins, CO
80526-8117
Dr. Gibbens,
I am contacting you today because I am
concerned about a significant number of primates who have died at
the SNBL facility in Alice, Texas.
I have obtained several records
relevant to the SNBL facility in Texas (2103 FM 625, Alice, TX
78332). These records reveal 3 primates whose deaths are a cause for
serious concern. Two of the SNBL primates, A10020, A10064, died of
“Mycobacterium Tuberculosis Complex” or Tuberculosis. Primate F08057
died of polioencephalomalacia, or goat polio. The severely
debilitated condition of this primate (including “ . . . a profound
regional lesion in the occipital cortex that consists of extensive
rarefaction of the grey matter,”) indicates a severely suffering
animal. Additionally, a condition of this type must raise serious
concerns regarding contagious spread to the rest of the primate
colony, as well as the origin of this disease, as would the two
cases of tuberculosis. All three of these deaths are causes for
concern regarding potential veterinary care 2.33 violations, as well
as being issues of Public Health concerns.
We are concerned that
these two facilities have both violated the Animal Welfare Act, and
that the SNBL facility of Alice, TX has also endangered public
health.
We believe that these incidents may indicate potential
violations of several sections of the Animal Welfare Act including
but not limited to: Section 2.33 Veterinary Care. (b)(2) The use of
appropriate methods to prevent, control, diagnose, and treat
diseases and injuries; and (b)(3) daily observation of animals.
Section 2.32 Personnel Qualifications, etc.
Since the documents in
my possession deal with only a fraction of the animals at the SNBL
lab, it is imperative that all other deaths at this facility caused
by infectious disease must be investigated as well.
As this
investigation is likely to bring to light more violations by the
SNBL facility, I must also insist that this facility receives the
maximum in penalties for these infractions, especially since these
incidents are directly relevant to the deaths of many animals, as
well as the safety of the general public.
I expect that your office
will reply to this correspondence within five business days.
Sincerely, Michael A. Budkie, A.H.T., Executive Director, SAEN
Attachments: Post-Mortem Records for SNBL Primates.
CC: OIG
See also:
- Monkeys Dying of TB and Polio at TX
Animal Dealer (SNBL) Become 'National Health Issue' Charges Watchdog
Group; Federal Investigations Demanded
Press Release
- Letter of
Complaint to Texas Department of Health, USFWS, Center for Disase
Control
SNBL USA Biosupport, LTD, Everett, WA
-
Diagnostic Laboratory Necropsy Report - 22 Oct 2010
SNBL USA Biosupport, LTD, Everett, WA
-
Diagnostic Laboratory Necropsy Report - 24 Nov 2010
SNBL USA Biosupport, LTD, Everett, WA
-
Diagnostic Laboratory Necropcy Report - 5 Aug 2010
SNBL USA Biosupport, LTD, Everett, WA
Rats, mice, birds, amphibians and other animals have been excluded from
coverage by the Animal Welfare Act. Therefore research facility reports
do not include these animals. As a result of this situation, a blank
report, or one with few animals listed, does not mean that a facility
has not performed experiments on non-reportable animals. A blank form
does mean that the facility in question has not used covered animals
(primates, dogs, cats, rabbits, guinea pigs, hamsters, pigs, sheep,
goats, etc.). Rats and mice alone are believed to comprise over 90% of
the animals used in experimentation. Therefore the majority of animals
used at research facilities are not even counted.
We welcome your comments and questions