A Meat and Dairy Article from All-Creatures.org

If Meat Is Cruel, So Is Dairy... The Hidden Truth for Vegetarians

From Juliane Priesemeister, Dairy-Truth.com
October 2024

Many vegetarians adopt their diet out of a desire to reduce animal suffering, driven by a belief that animals shouldn not be killed for food. Ethical vegetarians recognize that animals have a right to live free from harm and exploitation, which makes the decision to avoid meat a natural extension of this belief. However, dairy is often overlooked. Because dairy cows aren’t killed for their milk right away, some believe that this makes dairy more acceptable. But when we look deeper, we find that dairy is built on the same exploitation and violence as the meat industry.

Images from Human Cruelties

For many vegetarians, cutting out meat feels like the most important step toward living more compassionately. But when it comes to dairy, things get more complicated.

Dairy products are everywhere—milk in coffee, cheese on pizza—and they’re often viewed as a harmless compromise. But is dairy really compatible with ethical values? The truth is, dairy is deeply linked to exploitation and death. The dairy industry is not separate from the meat industry; they are inextricably tied by one cruel system that treats animals as resources, not living beings. This post will explore whether ethical vegetarians should continue consuming dairy and why it’s essential to consider leaving it behind.

Why Are You Vegetarian?

Many vegetarians adopt their diet out of a desire to reduce animal suffering, driven by a belief that animals shouldn’t be killed for food. Ethical vegetarians recognize that animals have a right to live free from harm and exploitation, which makes the decision to avoid meat a natural extension of this belief. However, dairy is often overlooked. Because dairy cows aren’t killed for their milk right away, some believe that this makes dairy more acceptable. But when we look deeper, we find that dairy is built on the same exploitation and violence as the meat industry.

Other vegetarians might choose the lifestyle for health or environmental reasons, not necessarily because of moral concerns. However, whether or not compassion was the initial motivation, understanding the ethical implications of dairy can provide a powerful reason to reconsider its place on the plate.

The Struggles with Ditching Dairy

Let’s be honest—dairy can be tough to quit. Cheese, in particular, seems to hold a special place in the hearts of many vegetarians, with some even calling it “addictive.” Its rich, creamy texture and comforting taste are hard to replace. For those who have already given up meat, the thought of giving up dairy can feel like a bridge too far.

The social pressure to keep dairy in the diet is another major hurdle. In restaurants, at family dinners, and in social gatherings, dairy seems like the “easy” option, the one food that keeps things simple. Add to that the cultural attachment to dairy—whether it’s a childhood favorite dish or a daily coffee ritual—and it’s easy to see why many vegetarians hold onto it. According to studies, this struggle is incredibly common​. But just like with eggs, overcoming these barriers is possible—and worth it.

The Cruel Truth About Dairy: More Than Just Milk

Here’s the reality that’s often hidden: dairy is not a “kind” or “harmless” industry. The dairy industry is built on a cycle of exploitation and killing. Dairy cows are constantly impregnated, only to have their calves taken from them soon after birth. Male calves, who cannot produce milk, are often sold for veal or killed outright. Female calves, meanwhile, are forced into the same cycle as their mothers—constant pregnancy and milking until their bodies can no longer keep up.

Images from Human Cruelties

When dairy cows’ milk production declines, they are no longer profitable to the industry. At that point, their value is measured by their meat, and they are sent to slaughter. The dairy and meat industries are closely connected, with dairy cows ending up as part of the meat supply chain once their bodies have been pushed to their limits.

Why All Vegetarians Should Care

For vegetarians who made the switch for health or environmental reasons, it’s important to ask—does supporting an industry built on suffering and killing really align with these values? The environmental footprint of dairy is significant, from the enormous land and water use required to the pollution caused by large-scale dairy farms. And from a health perspective, dairy is high in saturated fat and cholesterol, which can contribute to long-term health issues.

Beyond health and the environment, there’s the simple question of whether animals should be treated as commodities. Even if compassion wasn’t the initial reason for going vegetarian, understanding the ethical implications of dairy can prompt a powerful re-evaluation of its place in a compassionate lifestyle.

Should Ethical Vegetarians Consume Dairy?

The answer is clear: No, ethical vegetarians should not consume dairy. The dairy industry is inseparable from the exploitation and killing of animals. Cows are treated as resources, used until their bodies are worn out, and then slaughtered. For anyone who believes in reducing animal suffering, continuing to consume dairy contradicts those values.

So, what’s the biggest challenge when it comes to ditching dairy? Is it the love of cheese? The convenience of milk? Many vegetarians struggle with these same issues, and it’s completely understandable. But with so many delicious plant-based alternatives available today—cashew cheese, oat milk, and more—there are easy ways to leave dairy behind without sacrificing the foods you love​.

---

Posted on All-Creatures.org: November 22, 2024
Return to Meat and Dairy Articles