ANNIVERSARY OF GRUESOME CHIMPANZEE DEATH AT COULSTON FDN.
PROMPTS CRITICISM OF USDA, CALL FOR FEDERAL CHARGES
Courtesy of Eric Kleiman and Suzanne Roy, IDA
Washington, DC (November 9, 2000) Today is the one-year
anniversary of the death of Donna, the 36-year-old ex-Air Force
chimpanzee who died a gruesome and excruciatingly painful death at The
Coulston Foundation (TCF) on November 9, 1999, In Defense of Animals
(IDA) announced. IDA is marking this tragic date by demanding that the
U.S. Department of Agriculture file formal charges against the New
Mexico-based primate testing lab for multiple violations of the Animal
Welfare Act that the agency has admitted it uncovered during an official
investigation that ended on May 26.
"One year has passed since Donna's gruesome, tragic
death, and the USDA still has taken no action against Coulston for the
abominable negligence that killed her," IDA program director Suzanne Roy
said. "Although nothing can bring Donna back, or erase the excruciating
pain that she needlessly suffered, we demand that some measure of
justice be served."
"We demand that the USDA enforce the law and file
federal charges immediately," Roy continued. "We will not allow Donna's
death to be in vain, or allow Coulston and the USDA to get away with
sweeping her egregious death under the rug."
USDA Western Regional Director Robert Gibbens, DVM, the
official directly responsible for enforcement of the Animal Welfare Act
at Coulston, flatly stated in a June 22, 2000 sworn affidavit that the
agency "anticipates" filing a formal complaint against Coulston based on
evidence uncovered during the USDA's investigation of Donna's death.
USDA launched the investigation after IDA made public the details of her
Four months after Dr. Gibbens filed the affidavit, the
USDA has apparently backtracked from that sworn statement. In an October
31 letter of response to four members of Congress inquiring about the
case, Agriculture Secretary Dan Glickman stated vaguely that the
agency's findings were currently under "review," and that it would take
"appropriate enforcement actions" if their "findings warrant it." The
USDA took over six weeks to write back to the members, despite repeated
requests by the Congressional offices for a response.
"The USDA continues to fiddle while Rome burns," said
Roy, noting that yet another chimpanzee - ten-year-old Ray - has died at
Coulston under extremely questionable circumstances, including an
apparent failure to provide veterinary care despite his being ill for
days. "How many more will die before the USDA acts appropriate[ly] on
the evidence of negligence it has had for over five months?"
Donna died from a massive infection after carrying a
large dead fetus she had carried in her womb for as long as two months.
She was literally rotting from the inside out when Coulston
veterinarians performed a belated C-section, removing one liter of pus
from her abdomen and observing the partially decomposed fetus's skull
through the ruptured wall of her uterus. Even then, TCF apparently did
not give permission to euthanize her, allowing Donna instead to awaken
from the nightmarish surgery in horrific condition. She died the next
Donna was a veteran of the U.S. Air Force's space
research program, and was "divested" to TCF by the Air Force in 1998.
Captured from the wilds of Africa at the tender age of 3, she spent the
rest of her life incarcerated at Holloman Air Force Base in the New
Mexico desert. There she was subjected to invasive procedures and tests
of drugs before being turned into a "breeding machine," with at least 14
babies born in 26 years (in the wild, chimpanzees normally breed at most
once every 6 years). According to the Air Force's behavioral profile,
Donna was an "excellent mother" who enjoyed grooming humans and
chimpanzees. According to Coulston nursery head Patty Cooper, Donna was
a good teacher to her fellow chimpanzees, "sweet, probably one of my
closest friends," and got along with everyone, human and nonhuman.
Coulston's website and promotional materials display a
photo of Donna cradling one of her 14 babies, Spudnut. Coulston also
shows a human baby and mother with the quote "This [human] mother and
child owe a lot to this [chimpanzee] mother and child."
"This sweet, gentle and nurturing chimpanzee died an
excruciatingly painful and gruesome death caused directly by Coulston's
egregious negligence," stated Roy. "Is that the Air Force's way of
honoring one of its veterans by dumping her at a lab with the worst
animal care record in history? Is that Coulston's way of showing
gratitude for Donna's 'sacrifice' in the name of Coulston 'science?'"
"We don't know which is worse: Coulston's actions, or
the USDA's inaction," said Roy. "Dr. Gibbens' sworn affidavit speaks
volumes about what the USDA found during its investigation and its
inaction since that time. Indeed, the USDA's failure thus far to act in
this matter makes a mockery of its oversight authority and
responsibility for research labs."
"What has happened to the USDA that, for years, has
worked diligently to enforce the Animal Welfare Act at Coulston?" Roy
asked. "Why has it failed to act for over five months on the serious
evidence of negligence that the agency itself uncovered? Has the USDA
simply given up, despite its admirable and unprecedented record of
upholding the law at TCF? Is it caving to political pressure from the
National Institutes of Health, which continues to support the lab
despite its unprecedented record of legal violations and negligent
"IDA will not rest until Donna receives some measure of
justice," Roy concluded. "We owe it to her, to Ray, to all of the
chimpanzees who have died from Coulston's gross negligence, and, perhaps
most importantly, to the survivors whose very lives remain at grave risk
while imprisoned in this abysmal lab."
A memoriam for Donna, including her picture, is located
at http://www.idausa.org. ore information can be found at
Go on to
Southeast Regional Compassion for Animals Action Symposium
Return to 29 November 2000 Issue
Return to Newsletters
** Fair Use Notice**
This document may contain copyrighted material, use of which has not been
specifically authorized by the copyright owners. I believe that this
not-for-profit, educational use on the Web constitutes a fair use of the
copyrighted material (as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright
Law). If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your
own that go beyond fair use, you must obtain permission from the copyright