John Robbins on the events of September 11th
Something truly terrible and tragic took place on
September 11th, 2001. If I could, by giving my life, somehow prevent
that from having occurred, I would do so in a heartbeat. I know I am not
alone in this.
But none of us can undo what has been done. The
question, now, is how will we respond?
Will we experience both our vulnerability and our unity
as a nation as never before? Will we see that even beset by such
terrifying death and destruction we are capable of compassion, courage,
heroism, and honor? Or will we do as the bin Ladens of the world would
want us to do, seeking revenge by retaliating with massive violence in
the Middle East, thus providing them with a new generation of suicidal
terrorists, eager to fight against "evil America" in this "holy war"?
I am no stranger to the desire for revenge. Like
President George W. Bush, and most likely like you, I have felt it surge
through me in recent days. Contemplating what took place on September
11th, are there any among us who have not, at least momentarily, felt
their blood boil with outrage, and with the demand that these mass
murderers and all those behind them pay with eye for an eye?
But at such times, when our hearts are filled with
bloodlust and our eyes look everywhere for revenge, it is
extraordinarily important that we remember the awesome truth behind
Gandhi's prophetic statement: "An eye for an eye will only make the
whole world blind."
This is the very truth that the Osama bin Ladens of the
world would want us to forget.
Bin Laden and his cronies have set a trap for us. It
would serve their purposes perfectly for us to mount indiscriminate and
ongoing air attacks on Afghanistan, killing enormous numbers of innocent
people, thus causing fanatics to flock to their cause. Do you think the
civilian population of Afghanistan would be protected in well prepared
underground hideouts? Not likely. But bin Laden and the Taliban rulers
would be. Nothing would please these deranged psychotics more than for
us to kill children in Kabul, thus enabling them to raise the armies of
terror they've always dreamed of. And even if we killed bin Laden in
such a bombing attack, it would only render him a martyr in the eyes of
those whose support he craves. The Osama bin Ladens of the world would
like to see our efforts cause extensive civilian casualties in
Afghanistan, because this would push even moderate Muslims toward hatred
of the United States.
There is one thing, though, that the bin Ladens of the
world would like even more than for us to mount a reckless bombing
attack on Afghanistan. And that would be for us to rush headlong into
Afghanistan with ground forces in an effort to control the country, for
such an attempt would only demonstrate before the whole world our
impotence and stupidity. Remember that the Soviet army tried for years,
and failed, and they had the advantage of being close at hand, knowing
the terrain, and they had numerous people who spoke the native
You could hardly think of a more effective way to
destabilize the peace-loving Moslem regimes upon whose support the
United States now depends. An American invasion of Afghanistan, for
example, could easily ignite a civil war in Pakistan, with the distinct
possibility that Pakistan's government, with its nuclear arms, would
then fall into the hands of extremists supportive of the Taliban. No
American response could better serve the terrorists' evil purposes.
If we are not to fall into the trap set by bin Laden and
his cohorts, what, then, are we to do?
I believe that we must ask the mainstream Islamic world
for advice. We must go to them and ask them what they would have us do.
And then we must listen to them, and deeply.
It is not the strength of our military and our ability
to punish that will enable us to meet this challenge, but the strength
of our hearts and our ability to listen. To form an alliance with
peace-loving Muslims, we will have to understand and take seriously
their concerns. This will mean reorienting our policies in the Middle
East - not, of course, to pacify the terrorists (who do not deserve to
be pacified, and could not be in any case), but to bring them to justice
in a way that undermines his purposes and retains the support of
moderate Muslim states. If we lose this support, we play into the hands
of the bin Ladens of the world, and risk world war.
It is critical that we remember that our problem is not
with Islam, or with Muslim people. Osama bin Laden no more represents
Islam than the Klu Klux Klan represents Christianity. Let us indict this
man and his cohorts as the mass murderers they are, and then, along with
our Islamic allies, bring them to world justice. Bin Laden and his
compatriots are not only enemies of the United States. They are enemies
of true Islam, and of the entire world community. For what took place on
September 11th was more than a crime against the United States. It was a
crime against humanity. People from 80 nations perished in the World
Trade Center, including hundreds of Muslims.
Domestically, it is crucial in these times that we go
out of our way to treat peace loving Arab Americans with respect and
friendship. A group of people in my local community have made themselves
available to Arab Americans, to go with them shopping if they would like
that, or to walk with their children on the way to school, or to stand
by and with them any time that they might feel unsafe or fear that they
might be scapegoated.
As we take steps to reduce the risk of further terrorist
attacks, we must proceed calmly and deliberately, bearing in mind the
need not to erode the liberties and freedoms that are at the core of the
American way of life. The true patriot is not the person who, in the
name of anti-terrorism, would target people because of their race,
religion, ethnic background, or appearance. The real American is the
person who would have us uphold the essential principals of a democratic
society. The American dream can be realized only in a world where
liberty and justice prevail for all.
Since the day he took office, President Bush has been
withdrawing from almost every multilateral agreement and international
treaty except those that enhance American profits and power. This is an
administration that has snubbed the world community and disengaged from
treaties attempting to deal with global warming, nuclear disarmament,
population control, trafficking in small arms, chemical and biological
weapons, to name just a few. This is an administration that has defined
American self-interest almost without regard for the concerns of other
nations, and sought to ram genetically engineered food and hormone laden
beef down the throats of the rest of the world. But now, suddenly, this
is an administration that desperately needs the help of the world. There
are signs of hope. As a London newspaper recently commented, "Colin
Powell, in a stunning and rare display of humility for an American
official, now acknowledges that in order to fight terrorism effectively
the U.S. is going to have to be more sensitive to the concerns of other
Might the United States remember in all of this that our
national purpose is greater than pursuing corporate profit, and that we
have a deep and paramount responsibility to the wellbeing of all of the
world's peoples? As the president of the State of the World Forum, Jim
Garrison, puts it: "If out of the present crisis the United States
emerges more connected with the rest of the world, more willing to
compromise national sovereignty within the context of the needs of the
larger community of nations, more willing to live cooperatively within
coalitions than outside them, then light will have truly come from out
of the darkness and redemption out of the recesses of hatred and war. In
one of the deepest paradoxes of contemporary history, the present crisis
might compel America to… (realize) no country is an island unique unto
itself…and the only solution to hate is to stop the underlying causes
that produce it, working within the community of nations to achieve
goals that benefit the poor as well as the rich, the south as well as
the north, the developing nations as well as those more advanced.
Achieving this, America will fulfill the deepest yearning of one of its
founding fathers, Benjamin Franklin, who wrote that he believed the real
destiny of America would not be about power; it would be about light."
If we would defeat terrorism then we must not only
defeat the individual bin Laden and his cohorts, but we must also defeat
the systemic injustice, exploitation and cruelty that provides fertile
soil for terrorism to flourish. We must take actions that will lead to a
thriving, just, and sustainable world for all, for this is the only kind
of world where terrorism can not take root. The bitter historical events
that came to fruition on September 11th did not come from nowhere, but
developed over decades and even centuries. Likewise the peace and
understanding that we seek, and which alone will make us truly safe,
need be nurtured and cultivated over generations of time.
It is to the planting, nurturing and harvesting of
fruits worthy of all that is good and beautiful in us that we must now,
as never before, dedicate our lives. Because now, as never before, the
world needs our wisdom, our cooperation, our affirmation of the human
spirit, and our understanding that all humanity is connected.
Go on to Living With
Return to 28 October 2001 Issue
Return to Newsletters
** Fair Use Notice**
This document may contain copyrighted material, use of which has not been
specifically authorized by the copyright owners. I believe that this
not-for-profit, educational use on the Web constitutes a fair use of the
copyrighted material (as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright
Law). If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your
own that go beyond fair use, you must obtain permission from the copyright