By Greg Lawson -
For those who need confirmation of their manliness,
there must be some special kind of satisfaction in that climatic moment
when they discharge their guns, shooting a full load of hot metal into a
wild furry creature. Apparently it is so satisfying that the sportsmen
of Montana will risk negative public opinion and will even violate
federal law to seek such pleasure.
Last spring, the Montana legislature passed the Bison
Sports Hunting Bill. In May it was signed into law by Governor Judy
Martz. The current Montana government doesn't seem to have learned from
the mistakes of the past. Bison hunting was allowed in the late 1980s,
but was discontinued in 1991 after massive national protest. The hunting
of bison around Yellowstone Park had hurt the state's image and their
The current bill was pushed through by the cattle
ranchers of Montana, the Department of Livestock. For more than the last
decade, the Montana DOL has been rounding up and killing Yellowstone
Park bison because ranchers have the unreasonable and unproven fear that
bison will spread disease to their cattle. The ranchers apparently felt
that if they could get hunters involved in the annual slaughter, it
would take some of the heat off of them.
When the Bison Sports Hunting Bill was debated last
spring, there was not one hunting organization that supported the bill.
Even hunters recognize that there is nothing sporting about "hunting"
bison. Bison have little fear of humans and will just stand there while
a "hunter" walks up to them and shoots them.
A few years ago, the state of Montana forced the federal
government to agree to the Interagency Bison Management Plan to control
the bison population of Yellowstone Park. According to the provisions of
this plan, hunting is not to be used as a method of managing the bison
herd. When Montana starts issuing bison hunting permits, the state will
be in violation of federal law.
A week ago, the Montana Fish, Wildlife and Parks
Commission gave tentative approval to the plan to allow bison hunting
around Yellowstone National Park. The Bison Sports Hunting bill passed
last spring allows bison hunting, but the plans must first approved by
state wildlife regulators of the FWPC.
An environmental impact study and a public comment
period must take place. This means that the first hunts will not happen
until the fall of 2004. Pat Flowers, regional supervisor for the Montana
FWPC, stated that he knows that bison hunting will be controversial.
"I'm anticipating 10,000 comment letters in the environmental review,"
he said in an interview last week with a Montana newspaper.
It is likely that the majority of letters will be
against hunting this majestic symbol of the American West. It is also
likely that the state of Montana will disregard public comments as they
have done in the past. The public comment period is just a formality
required by law.
Buffalo Field Campaign is a grassroots activist group
working in the field everyday to protect the bison. BFC is headquartered
in the town of West Yellowstone and is currently gearing up for the
winter season, a time when the Yellowstone bison face the greatest
danger from the cattle ranchers of the Montana Department of Livestock.
On August 25, Yellowstone Park officials, members of the
public and the media met in Gardiner, Montana, in a ceremony to
celebrate the 100th year anniversary of the Roosevelt Arch. The arch is
a large stone gateway at the north entrance to Yellowstone. Members of
the Buffalo Field Campaign were there as well.
As Yellowstone Park Superintendent Suzanne Lewis
approached the podium, BFC volunteers unfurled a large banner on a
hillside behind her. The banner read, "Buffalo Slaughter, an American
Tradition." The BFC called attention to the hypocrisy of Yellowstone
officials celebrating their commitment to wildlife when just last March,
Yellowstone rangers captured and sent to slaughterhouses 231 buffalo.
Park officials said they were acting under provisions of the Interagency
Bison Management Plan.
To learn more about this issue, to find out how the BFC
works to stop the annual slaughter of the bison and to learn how you can
help the BFC, please visit their website at
Go on to Hunting Statistics and Examples 1977-2001
Return to 21 September 2003 Issue
Return to Newsletters
** Fair Use Notice**
This document may contain copyrighted material, use of which has not been
specifically authorized by the copyright owners. I believe that this
not-for-profit, educational use on the Web constitutes a fair use of the
copyrighted material (as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright
Law). If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your
own that go beyond fair use, you must obtain permission from the copyright