See the commentary by Martin V. Cisneros upon which this discussion is based:
Hosea 2:18: God's New Covenant between Man and Animal
I enjoyed your article on Hosea 2:15. I so want to believe I will see my Beloved pets, in Heaven, but what is your understanding of Ecclesiastes 3:21?
Do you believe animals have souls?
If so; why does Ecclesiastes 3:21 indicate otherwise?
Thank-you and God bless.