Stephen Kaufman, M.D., Christian Vegetarian Association (CVA)
Animals as Victims of Scapegoating
It is always tempting to blame other individuals for our own
shortcomings, because this helps preserves our self-esteem. Attributing our
own guilt to other individuals is the essence of scapegoating, and nonhumans
are ideal candidates for such a process for several reasons.
Nonhumans cannot verbally challenge false charges against them. They are
relatively weak compared to humans and vulnerable to human mistreatment.
Human communities, particularly those needing fellow humans to assist in
farming, hunting, or defense, find animals far more expendable and
replaceable than humans. And, probably most importantly, animals can be
punished or otherwise abused without risk of retaliation from family
members, friends, or others.
Routinely, animals destined for murder at human hands are regarded as
vicious, licentious, stupid, ugly, or otherwise contemptible and undeserving
of sympathy. Next essay, I will argue that these characterizations, which
are essential to the process of scapegoating animals, are false.
Go on to: Who Are the Animals People Abuse?
Return to:
Reflection on the Lectionary, Table of Contents