Meat Free Zone
Articles - Health & Nutrition

Home
Introduction
Our Mission
Who We Are
Articles
Articles - Health
Testimonials
Contact Us
Discussion Boards
Help Us
MFZ Sightings
Free MFZ Kits
MFZ in India
MFZ Stuff

T-Shirts
Totes
Magnets
Tank Tops
Aprons
Order

Links

Woodstock Animal Rights Movement

A Store For Life

P. O. Box 746
Woodstock, NY 12498 USA

Homeopathy - Still Crazy After All These Years

by Harriet Hall, MD

Homeopathy is one of the longest running forms of pseudoscience in the modern world. Oliver Wendell Holmes recognized that it was nonsense back in 1842 when he wrote ďHomeopathy and Its Kindred Delusions.Ē We long ago gave up the nonsense of trying to balance the four humors by bloodletting and purging, but the homeopathy Energizer Bunny is still marching on. What makes it so indestructible?

One reason is a lack of understanding about what homeopathy really is, even among health care providers. I recently heard about a nurse who thought ďhomeopathicĒ just referred to any mild natural herbal remedy. In case any readers are similarly confused, hereís a brief overview. Homeopathy was invented by Samuel Hahnemann in the late 1700s. It is based on the now-outdated principle that ďlike cures like,Ē and the lower the dose the better in homeopathy. If coffee keeps you awake, highly diluted coffee will put you to sleep. The more dilute the coffee, the better you will sleep.

To figure out what remedy works for what symptoms, you do a ďprovingĒ by giving a substance to healthy people and writing down every symptom they have for the next few days (without trying to determine whether the symptom was due to the substance or was just coincidental). You make a remedy by diluting that substance many times and shaking it (succussing) at each step. You look up a patientís symptoms in a book listing all the different proving results, and you give him the remedy that best matches what ails him.

For one remedy, the book lists symptoms in 19 body systems, with entries such as this one: ďPain in back, with desire for some firm support. Every movement accelerates the circulation. Palms hot and perspiring. Nasal discharge or dry nose. Hangnails. Warts. Chill between 9 and 11 AM. Coldness of legs with congestion to head, chest, and stomach. Sleepy in forenoon. Dreams of robbersÖĒ It goes on like that for pages. All of those symptoms were reported in provings by healthy people after they ingested Natrum muriaticum. Thatís table salt. How could anyone seriously believe that table salt causes all those symptoms, or for that matter believe that a dilute salt solution could relieve all those symptoms?

How dilute? Serious dilution, as in comparable to one drop diluted in all the water on Earth. When they realized that no molecules of the original substance were left in most homeopathic dilutions, homeopaths rationalized that the water must ďrememberĒ what it had come into contact with ó as in clusters of water molecules somehow holding the memory of their encounters with the allegedly curative substances. Unfortunately, homeopaths have failed to explain how water can remember what itís supposed to remember, and forget all the other memories of coming into contact with various trace contaminants, elements, bacteria, and whatever else happened to float by at the time.

In homeopathy, any substance can be a remedy; even a non-substance. My favorite is ďeclipsed moonlight.Ē Iíve been trying to find out how they collect it to prepare the remedy; no oneís talking. And then there was the homeopath who was selling homeopathic vaccines for smallpox and anthrax, which he said were made by diluting the real thing. I reported him to Homeland Security, because if he can get the real thing, so can terrorists. Jacques Benveniste is infamous for winning two IgNobel prizes for homeopathy studies: the first one couldnít be replicated when proper blinding controls were used; in the second one, he claimed to have sent the electronic signature of the remedy over the Internet.

The Benveniste basophile degranulation study was a convoluted attempt to show that water could remember. It was supposedly replicated in other labs, notably by Ennis. Homeopaths are still citing these studies as evidence for the memory of water, but this is intellectually dishonest. In the first place, the studies are completely discredited by the fact that every attempt to repeat them with proper blinding has failed. When James Randi and a team from Nature visited Benvenisteís lab, his experiment stopped working. When Ennisís experiment was repeated for Randiís million dollar prize on the BBC show Horizon, it failed. If the experiment really worked under proper blinding conditions, someone could have easily won the million dollars by now.

In the second place, homeopaths donít seem to realize that if the results of those experiments were valid, it would mean that homeopathy couldnít possibly work as advertised. The effects went up and down with consecutive dilutions rather than steadily upwards, and it appears that they got a similar effect from a dilution as from the full strength solution, rather than getting the expected opposite effect.

Homeopathy is about as silly as it gets. Silly wouldnít matter if it worked, but it doesnít. People think it works because they get placebo effects and the homeopath keeps them entertained while they get better on their own.

One recent meta-analysis claimed to have found that homeopathy worked better than a placebo in general, but that it didnít work better than placebo for any specific condition. Iím still trying to wrap my brain around that. Thatís like saying broccoli is good for all people but it isnít good for men or women or children. Other meta-analyses have been negative, especially the ones that looked at only the higher quality studies. A recent editorial in the British medical journal Lancet proclaimed ďThe end of homeopathy.Ē

Perhaps the most promising development is that Edzard Ernst, MD, has spoken out strongly against homeopathy. This is important because he was a practicing homeopath and the worldís first professor of complementary medicine. For the last 15 years he has led a team of researchers studying the evidence for alternative medicine, and he now concludes, ďWith respect to homeopathy, the evidence points towards a bogus industry that offers patients nothing more than a fantasy.Ē

Despite science and reason, homeopathy isnít about to go away. It has some really good things going for it. When you visit a homeopath, he wants to know all about you. He gives you far more time and attention than your MD does. He picks a special treatment designed just for you. If itís not working he has an explanation and something else to try next time. Heís always confident he can help you get better. Homeopathy is inexpensive. It has no side effects. Itís the ideal placebo. Itís great for the worried well and the hypochondriac. Itís great for those elusive symptoms scientific medicine cannot diagnose and cure. Itís harmless except in cases where patients are persuaded to forgo effective medical treatment, or when homeopathic vaccines are offered in lieu of real vaccines.

Itís popular in Great Britain where Queen Elizabeth uses it, Prince Charles promotes it, five homeopathic hospitals are still operating, and the National Health Service is paying a good chunk of its budget for it.

Letís say you arenít sleeping well. You could go to an MD and get a prescription sleeping pill that only works a little better than a placebo and has side effects, or you could go to a homeopath and get a placebo that has no side effects and is a lot cheaper. Youíre probably better off with the placebo. Why donít MDs prescribe placebos? Because itís unethical: we donít lie to patients; we canít tell them a remedy is effective if we know it is no more effective than a sugar pill.

Itís easy to see how doctors could be persuaded that homeopathy works. Patients tell them they feel better. Thatís why bloodletting and purging lasted so long: patients got better despite the treatment and the treatment got the credit. Thatís why we have to do randomized controlled trials to make sure just as many patients donít get better without treatment.

The arguments homeopaths use to support their beliefs would earn an F in a Logic 101 course. Here are just a few taken from ďPresenting 50 Facts About HomeopathyĒ by Louise Mclean.

  • Hippocrates said there was a law of similars. [Hippocrates also said all illness was due to an imbalance of the four humors.]
  • Homeopathic provings are a more scientific method of testing than the orthodox model. [If you say something totally false often enough, someone might start to belief it.]
  • There are more than 4000 homeopathic remedies. [None of which work]
  • The exact substance in a homeopathic remedy is known, unlike most modern drugs where we are rarely informed of the ingredients. [What? We are informed if we know how to read!]
  • Homeopaths treat genetic illness, tracing its origins to six main genetic causes: Tuberculosis, Syphilis, Gonorrhea, Psora (scabies), Cancer, Leprosy. [Geneticists would be surprised to hear this.]
  • Homeopathy got better results than conventional treatment in epidemics of cholera and typhoid in the 19th century. [Only because 19th century conventional treatment did more harm than good. Todayís conventional medicine is a bit more effective.]
  • Lots of people believe in homeopathy. [Lots of people believe in ghosts and angels, but that doesnít make them real.]
  • Big Pharma doesnít want us to know how well homeopathy works. [Conspiracy theories are alive and well.]
  • Queen Elizabeth never travels anywhere without her homeopathic vials of medicine. [And Madonna uses Kabbalah water.]
  • Arguments like these just highlight the intellectual bankruptcy of the homeopathic belief system. They would love to find scientific validation, but they reject science when it doesnít support them. One repeated excuse is that the remedies are individualized so they donít lend themselves to controlled trials. Thatís just nonsense. A homeopath could prescribe individualized remedies and third parties could randomly dispense either what had been prescribed or a placebo control. Neither patient nor homeopath would know which the patient got.

    Homeopathy was humbug in 1842. Itís still humbug today. Thatís a diagnosis you can prescribe to everyone.

    Return to Health & Nutrition Articles


    Fair Use Notice: This document may contain copyrighted material whose use has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owners. We believe that this not-for-profit, educational use on the Web constitutes a fair use of the copyrighted material (as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law). If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond fair use, you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

    Your comments are welcome

    The Meat Free Zone (MFZ) campaign is intended to make the MeatFreeZone logo as recognizable a symbol as the "Smoke Free Zone". The idea was originally conceived  when The WARM Store in Woodstock, NY, was in operation throughout the '90's (Woodstock Animal Rights Movement)  The store was truly a meat free zone as it was the first cruelty-free, Vegan, socially conscious animal rights store in the United States.  Now  that  the Vegan and Vegetarian movements have been growing so rapidly, more and more people are showing concern about the food in their diet and their overall  health and nutrition.  Many people are giving up eating fish, chicken, beef, pork (pigs ), dairy (milk, cheese, yogurt, ice cream) and eggs.  Headlines of Mad Cow disease E-coli and salmonella are in the news with greater frequency.  Vegan and vegetarian recipe cookbooks are standard now  in all bookstores and many restaurants have added Vegan and Vegetarian options to their menus. We hope you will help us with the Meat Free Zone campaign by putting the signs up in your homes and workplaces and by spreading them to all the vegetarian and vegan restaurants that you know and frequent.  And someday we will have true "meat free zones" in establishments that serve meat.

    This site is hosted and maintained by:
    The Mary T. and Frank L. Hoffman Family Foundation
    Thank you for visiting all-creatures.org.
    Since date.gif (991 bytes)